Pages

Monday, October 09, 2006

Quickie Allen vs. Webb Debate Review

How many times did Allen invoke the name of Hillary Clinton? Was it double figures? It certainly seemed more than I heard him say “George Bush.” Maybe I’m wrong. Allen managed to work Ted Kennedy in a few times, as well.

Most important -- Allen kept his temper. He spoke exclusively to his base, saying I’m OK, don’t worry. We’re still in this together. He mentioned 9/11 and lowering taxes whenever he could. Yet, Allen seemed more self-conscious than I remember him being in past debates.

On a zero-to-10 scale Allen’s overall performance gets a five from SLANTblog.

Jim Webb revealed more of his thoughtful style than I’ve seen before from him, while standing behind a microphone. He probably didn’t score as well on Iraq as he needed. He built the case that intellectually he is indeed a Democrat; on that Webb was keen and focused.

Moreover, Webb appeared more comfortable with the stress of the live confrontation under the lights than his opponent. Accordingly, Webb gets a seven from SLANTblog for his overall performance.

While neither man scored a knockout, Webb was the clear winner in my view. With no traction from tonight’s effort Allen’s negative momentum continues.

Bottom line: My first sense of the debate -- which was well-run -- is that I can’t see how Allen will feel all that good about how he did on stage. And, Webb is probably all smiles as I’m writing this.

No comments:

Post a Comment